Table of Contents

Governing Disasters

Governing Disasters

The Challenges of Emergency Risk Regulation

Edited by Alberto Alemanno

This is the first volume that addresses the complexities of the volcanic ash cloud that overshadowed Europe in April 2011, but has subsequently struck again in Australia, Chile and Europe. It does so from a multidisciplinary perspective, drawing upon research from economics, law, sociology and other fields, as well as volcanology and leading expertise in jet engineering. Whilst our knowledge base is wide-ranging, there is a common focus on the practical lessons of the ash cloud crisis both for subsequent eruptions and for emergency risk regulation more generally.

Chapter 2: Which Risk and Who Decides When There Are So Many Players?

Donald Macrae

Subjects: economics and finance, transport, environment, disasters, transport, law - academic, european law, regulation and governance, politics and public policy, public policy, urban and regional studies, transport


Donald Macrae 2.1 INTRODUCTION There was a time that a voyage across the North Atlantic involved praying to Thor and Odin for calm seas and favourable winds but these old practices have fallen into disuse. For a few months in 2010, prayers may have become appropriate again, for favourable winds to blow away the cloud of volcanic ash that could prevent a flight to North America from many places in Europe. Whether modern risk-management systems are more effective than praying to the Norse gods is beyond the scope of this chapter but we certainly saw a time when many of the advances of modern life disappeared and Fate seemed to reassert itself in all its pre-Cartesian power. To have been a catastrophe, people would have had to have died and it is a feature of this incident that nobody is know to have died as a direct result of volcanic ash in jet engines. But the image of catastrophic engine failure that captured imaginations in the first two days soon faded as millions of lesser disasters and inconveniences surfaced across the globe. It was a remarkable instance of the possibility of a severe loss being set against the certainty of multiple lesser losses, a risk equation that is always difficult to manage. It all seemed a bit of a mess as well. Could it have been handled better? This chapter tries to analyze the situation using the methodology developed by the UK’s Risk and Regulation Advisory Council to manage...

You are not authenticated to view the full text of this chapter or article.

Elgaronline requires a subscription or purchase to access the full text of books or journals. Please login through your library system or with your personal username and password on the homepage.

Non-subscribers can freely search the site, view abstracts/ extracts and download selected front matter and introductory chapters for personal use.

Your library may not have purchased all subject areas. If you are authenticated and think you should have access to this title, please contact your librarian.

Further information