The Legal Protection of Databases

The Legal Protection of Databases

A Comparative Analysis

Estelle Derclaye

The protection of the investment made in collecting, verifying or presenting database contents is still not harmonised internationally. Some laws over-protect database contents, whilst others under-protect them. This book examines and compares several methods available for the protection of investment in database creation – namely, intellectual property, unfair competition, contract and technological protection measures – in order to find an adequate type and level of protection. To this effect, the author uses criteria based on a combination of the economics of information goods, the human rights to intellectual property and to information, and the public interest, proposing a model that can be adopted at international and national levels.

Chapter 4: The Protection of Databases by Contract in Europe

Estelle Derclaye

Subjects: law - academic, information and media law, intellectual property law


Introduction As we have seen in Chapter 3, Article 13 of the Directive allows database producers to protect their databases contractually in addition to the sui generis right. The same problems of possible over-protection identified in the last chapter therefore arise. Chapter 4 is concerned with two questions. First, is it over-protective to allow database producers to obtain additional protection for their sui generis right-protected database by contract, over and above the protection granted by the sui generis right (simultaneous over-protection)? In other words, is it over-protective to override the limits of the sui generis right by contract (section 2)? Secondly, is it over-protective to allow contractual protection of databases not protected by the sui generis right, either because they were protected but have now fallen into the public domain or because they do not meet the requirements to be protected by the sui generis right (over-protection a posteriori and negative over-protection) (section 3)? The aim of the analysis is not to determine whether such contracts are valid under contract law. This will be assumed. The chapter will only concentrate on the issue underlying the two identified questions, namely whether certain use of contracts over-protects database producers. Before tackling these questions, two types of contracts must be distinguished as their effects are different (section 1). 1 Fully negotiated and adhesion contracts Database producers can protect their databases by fully negotiated contracts (or contracts at arm’s length) or by adhesion (or standard form) contracts. When a contract is fully negotiated, parties...

You are not authenticated to view the full text of this chapter or article.

Elgaronline requires a subscription or purchase to access the full text of books or journals. Please login through your library system or with your personal username and password on the homepage.

Non-subscribers can freely search the site, view abstracts/ extracts and download selected front matter and introductory chapters for personal use.

Your library may not have purchased all subject areas. If you are authenticated and think you should have access to this title, please contact your librarian.

Further information