A deliberative approach to inter-parliamentary debate sees inter-regional parliamentary assemblies as promoters of dialogue and mutual understanding, rather than as decision-making bodies. This chapter assesses the quality of deliberation in the Joint Parliamentary Assembly of the European Union and Africa, the Caribbean and the Pacific (ACP-EU JPA) through the development of an analytical framework based on the theoretical perspective of parliamentary deliberation. This framework is applied to analyse the quality of the ACP-EU JPA debates on the Economic Partnership Agreements, which is a strongly divisive subject in ACP–EU relations and which the ACP-EU JPA achieves consensus on. Ultimately, the analysis finds that the ACP–EU JPA dialogue on Economic Partnership Agreements struggles to approach the ideal type of deliberation due to recurring critical issues. Nevertheless, the evidence demonstrates that the ACP-EU JPA as an illustration of deliberation can be considered added value for inter-parliamentary cooperation between the EU and the ACP.
Sarah Delputte and Yentyl Williams
Sarah Delputte and Jan Orbie
Although the European Union (EU) has always been a major actor in international development, literature on development policy within the discipline of EU studies is relatively limited in terms of quantity and relatively light in terms of theorizing. Against this background, we propose an abductive research strategy, involving a continuous interaction between theory and empirics, to study EU development policy. We also present clear guidelines on how to engage in abductive research and illustrate this approach with illustrations from our own research on four case studies: (1) EU coordination in sub-Saharan Africa, (2) the rise of Policy Coherence for Development, (3) the changing development consensus in the EU, and (4) the Europeanization of aid. Hence the dual objectives of this chapter: first, to argue why abduction is useful and even necessary for studying EU development policy, and second, to illustrate concretely how this can be done in practice.