Show Less
You do not have access to this content

Administrative Justice in the UN

Procedural Protections, Gaps and Proposals for Reform

Niamh Kinchin

The UN’s capacity as an administrative decision-maker that affects the rights of individuals is a largely overlooked aspect of its role in international affairs. This book explores the potential for a model of administrative justice that might act as a benchmark to which global decision-makers could develop procedural standards. Applied to the UN’s internal justice, refugee status determination, NGO participation and the Security Council, the global administrative justice model is used to appraise the existing procedural protections within UN administrative decision-making.
Show Summary Details
This content is available to you


Niamh Kinchin

Aaronson, Susan Ariel and M. Rodwan Abouharb ‘Is more trade always better? The WTO and human rights in conflict zones’ (2013) 47 (5) Journal of World Trade

Adler, Michael ‘A Socio-Legal Approach to Administrative Justice’ (2003) 25 Law and Policy

Albert, Matthew ‘Primafacie Determination of Refugee Status: An Overview and Its Legal Foundation’ (2010) Working Paper Series No. 55, Refugee Studies Centre, Oxford University

Alexander, Lawrence ‘The Relationship between Procedural Due Process and Substantive Constitutional Rights’ (1987) 39 University of Florida Law Review

Alexander, Michael ‘Refugee Status Conducted by UNHCR’ (1999) 11 International Journal of Refugee Law

Aman Jr, Alfred C. ‘Administrative Law for a New Century’ in Michael Taggart (ed.) Province of Administrative Law (Hart Publishing, 1997)

Aman Jr, Alfred C. ‘Globalization, Democracy and the Need for a New Administrative Law’ (2003) 10 Indiana Journal of Global Legal Studies

Aman, Jr, Alfred C. The Democracy Deficit: Taming Globalization through Law Reform (New York University Press, 2004)

Amerasinghe, Chittharanjan Felix Principles of the Institutional Law of International Organizations (Cambridge University Press, 2nd edn, 2003)

Arato, Julian ‘Treaty Interpretation and Constitutional Transformation: Informal Change in International Organizations’ (2013) 38 Yale Journal of International Law

Austin, John The Provence of Jurisprudence Determined (Noonday Press, 1st edn, 1954)

Barnett, Michael and Martha Finnemore Rules for the World: International Organizations in Global Politics (Cornell University Press, 2004)

Barnett, Michael and Martha Finnemore ‘The power in liberal international organisation’ in Michael N. Barnett and Raymond Duvall (eds), Power in Global Governance (Cambridge University Press, 2005)

Battini, Stefano ‘International Organizations and Private Subjects: A Move Toward a Global Administrative Law?’ (Working Paper No. 2005/3, Institute for International Law and Justice (NYU), 2005)

Bernardez, Santiago Torres ‘Les organes des organisations internationales’ in R.J. Dupuy (ed.), Manuel sur les organisations internationales (Martinus Nijhoff, 1998)

Bernhardt, Rudolf ‘Qualifikation und Anwendungsbereich des internen Rechts internationaler Organisationen’ (1973) 12 Berichte der Deutschen Gesellschaft für Völkerrecht

Bignami, Francesca ‘Comparative Administrative Law’ (Public Law and Legal Theory Paper No. 2012-115, The George Washington University Law School, 2012)

Boon, Kristen E. ‘The United Nations as Good Samaritan: Immunity and Responsibility’ (2015–2016) 16 Chinese Journal of International Law

Bovens, Mark ‘Two Concepts of Accountability: Accountability as a Virtue and as a Mechanism’ (2010) 33 Western European Politics

Bovens, Mark ‘Analysing and Assessing Accountability: A Conceptual Framework’ (2007) 13 European Law Journal

Bradley, A.W. ‘Administrative Justice: A Developing Human Right? (1995) 1 (3) European Public Law

Brownlie, Ian Principles of International Law (Oxford University Press, 7th edn, 2008)

Buchanan, Allen ‘Human Rights and the Legitimacy of the International Order’ (2008) 14 Legal Theory

Buchanan, Allen and Robert O. Keohane ‘The Legitimacy of Global Governance Institutions’ (2006) 20 Ethics & International Affairs

Cassese, Sabino ‘A Global Due Process of Law?’ in Gordon Anthony, Jean-Bernard Auby, John Morison and Tom Zwart (eds), Values in Global Administrative Law (Hart Publishing, 2011)

Chesterman, Simon ‘An International Rule of Law?’ (2008) 56 American Journal of Comparative Law

Chimni, B.S. ‘Co-option and Resistance: Two Faces of Global Administrative Law’ (2005) 37 New York University Journal of International Law and Politics

Chimni, B.S. ‘Global Administrative Law: Winners and Losers’, Paper presented at the NYU Law School Colloquium on Global Administrative Law, April 2005

Chinkin, Caroline ‘The Challenge of Soft Law: Development and Change in International Law’ (1989) 38 (4) The International and Comparative Law Quarterly

Conkle, Daniel O. ‘Three Theories of Substantive Due Process’ (2006) 85 North Carolina Law Review

Corkery, Alison ‘The Contribution of the UNHCR Executive Committee to the Development of International Refugee Law’ (2006) 13 Australian International Law Journal

Crawford, James ‘International Law and the Rule of Law’ (2003) 24 Adelaide Law Review

Creyke, Robin ‘Administrative Justice in Context – Towards Integrity in Government’ (2007) 31 Melbourne University Law Review

Creyke, Robin and John McMillan ‘Administrative Justice – The Concept Emerges’ in Robin Creyke and John McMillan (eds), Administrative Justice – The Core and the Fringe (Australian Institute of Administrative Law, 2000)

Cuellar, Mariano-Florentino ‘Refugee Security and the Organizational Logic of Legal Mandates’ (2006) 37 (4) Georgetown Journal of International Law

d’Aspremont, Jean ‘The multifaceted concept of autonomy of international organizations and international legal discourse’ in Richard Collins and Nigel D. White (eds), International Organizations and the Idea of Autonomy (Routledge, 2011)

de Wet, Erika ‘Human Rights and the Rule of Law as Applicable to the UNSC’ in Clemens A. Feinaugle (ed.), The Rule of Law and its Application to the United Nations (Hart Publishing, 2016)

Denza, Eileen ‘Diplomatic Agents and Missions, Privileges and Immunities’ in Rudolf Bernhardt (ed.), Encyclopaedia of Public International Law (North Holland Publishing Co, 2nd edn, 1992) Vol I

Derrida, Jacques On the Name (Stanford University Press, 1995)

Dimitropoulos, Georgios ‘A Common GAL: The Legitimating Role of the Global Rule of Law’, Paper presented at the Viterbo Seminar on Global Administrative Law, Viterbo, Italy, 13–14 June 2008

Domingo, Rafael The New Global Law (Cambridge University Press, 2010)

Durieux, J.F. and A. Hurwitz ‘How many is too many: African and European legal responses to mass influxes of refugees’ (2005) 47 German Yearbook of International Law

Dyzenhaus, David ‘The Legitimacy of Legality’ (1996) 46 University of Toronto Law Journal

Dyzenhaus, David ‘The Rule of (Administrative) Law in International Law’ (2005) 68 Law and Contemporary Problems

Dyzenhaus, David ‘Accountability and the Concept of (Global) Administrative Law’ (2009) Acta Juridica

Ellis, Ron Unjust by Design: Canada’s Administrative Justice System (UBC Press, 2013)

Fallon Jr, Richard H. ‘“The Rule of Law” as a Concept in Constitutional Discourse’ (1997) 97 Columbia Law Review

Farrall, Jeremy Matam United Nations Sanctions and the Rule of Law (Cambridge University Press, 2007)

Ferejohn, John ‘Accountability in a Global Context’ (Working Paper No. 2007/5, Institute for International Law and Justice (NYU), 2007)

Finn, Paul ‘Public Trust and Public Accountability’ (1994) 3 Griffith Law Review

Franck, Thomas ‘The Emerging Right to Democratic Governance’ (1982) 86 (46) The American Journal of International Law

French, Justice R.S. ‘Judicial Review Rights’ (2001) 28 Australian Institute of Administrative Law Forum

Fuller, Lon L. ‘Positivism and Fidelity to Law: A Reply to Professor Hart’ (1958) 71 Harvard Law Review

Fuller, Lon L. The Morality of Law (Yale University Press, revised edition, 1969)

Galligan, Denis J. Discretionary Powers: A Legal Study of Official Discretion (Clarendon Press, 2006)

Galligan, Denis J., Richard H. Langan and Nicandrou S. Constance Administrative Justice in the New European Democracies: Case Studies of Administrative Law and Process in Bulgaria, Estonia, Hungary, Poland and Ukraine (Open Society Institute, Constitutional and Legal Policy Institute and Centre for Socio-Legal Studies, University of Oxford)

Genser, Jared and Kate Barth ‘Targeted Sanctions and Due Process of Law’ in Jared Gener and Bruno Stagno Ugarte (eds), The United Nations Security Council in the Age of Human Rights (Cambridge University Press, 2014)

Gill, Chris ‘The Evolving Role of the Ombudsman: A Conceptual and Constitutional Analysis of the “Scottish Solution” to Administrative Justice’ (2014) (Autumn) Public Law

Goldring, Jack ‘Accountability of Commonwealth Statutory Authorities and “Responsible Government”’ (1980) 11 Federal Law Review

Goldsmith, Jack L. and Eric A. Posner The Limits of International Law (Oxford University Press, 2005)

Goodwin-Gill, Guy ‘Refugee Identity and Protection’s Fading Prospect’ in Francis Nicholson and Patrick Twomey (eds), Refugee Rights and Realities: Evolving International Concepts and Regimes (Cambridge University Press, 1999)

Grant, Ruth W. and Robert O. Keohane ‘Accountability and Abuses of Power in World Politics’ (2005) 99 American Political Science Review

Groves, Matthew ‘Administrative Justice in Australian Administrative Law’ (2011) 66 AIAL Forum

Habermas, Jurgen ‘Human Rights and Popular Sovereignty: The Liberal and Republican Versions’ (1994) 7 Ratio Juris

Habermas, Jurgen ‘Private and Public Autonomy, Human Rights and Popular Sovereignty’ (1994) 1 Graven Images

Habermas, Jurgen ‘Human Dignity and the Realistic Utopia of Human Rights’ (2010) 41 (4) Metaphilosophy

Halliday, Simon ‘Ideal Conditions of Impact: Some Reflections on the Influence of Judicial Review on Administrative Decision Making’, Paper presented to the Law Program, Research School of the Social Sciences, Australian National University, 5 September 2001, Canberra

Halliday, Simon and Colin Scott ‘A Cultural Analysis of Administrative Justice’ in Michael Adler (ed.), Administrative Justice in Context (Hart Publishing, 2010)

Happold, Matthew ‘United Nations Sanctions and the Rule of Law’ in Clemens A. Feinaugle (ed.), The Rule of Law and its Application to the United Nations (Hart Publishing, 2016)

Harlow, Carol ‘Global Administrative Law: The Quest for Principles and Values’ (2006) 17 European Journal of International Law

Harlow, Carol and Richard Rawlings Law and Administration (Butterworths, 2nd edn, 1997)

Hart, H.L.A. The Concept of Law (Clarendon Press, 2nd edn, 1994)

Hathaway, James C. The Law of Refugee Status (Butterworths, 1996)

Hayek, F.A. The Political Idea of the Rule of Law (National Bank of Egypt, 1955)

Held, David Democracy and the Global Order (Stanford University Press, 2005)

Hoexter, Cora ‘Administrative Action in the Courts’ (2006) Acta Juridica

Holborn, Louise W. Refugees; A Problem of our Time: The Work of the United Nations Commissioner for Refugees 1951–1972 (Scarecrow Press, 1975)

Hovell, Devika ‘Due Process in the United Nations’ (2016) 110 American Journal of International Law

Jackson, Ivor The Refugee Concept in Group Situations (Springer, 1999)

Jowell, Jeffrey ‘The Democratic Necessity of Administrative Justice’ (2006) 13 Acta Juridica

Kagan, Michael ‘The Beleaguered Gatekeeper: Protection Challenges Posed by UNHCR Refugee Status Determination’ (2006) 18 International Journal of Refugee Law

Kelsen, Hans General Theory of Law and State (A. Wedberg tr, Harvard University Press, 1945)

Kelsen, Hans Pure Theory of Law (The Lawbook Exchange Ltd, 2002)

Keohane, Robert O. ‘Global Governance and Legitimacy’ (2011) 18 (1) Review of International Political Economy

Kinchin, Niamh ‘The Implied Human Rights Obligations of UNHCR’ (2016) 28 (2) International Journal of Refugee Law

Kingsbury, Benedict ‘The Concept of “Law” in Global Administrative Law’ (Working Paper No. 2009/1, Institute for International Law and Justice (NYU), 2009)

Kingsbury, Benedict, Nico Krisch and Richard B. Stewart ‘The Emergence of Global Administrative Law’ (2005) 68 (3&4) Law and Contemporary Problems 15

Klabbers, Jan An Introduction to International Institutional Law (Cambridge University Press, 2002)

Kokott, Julian and Christoph Sobotta ‘The Kadi Case – Constitutional Core Values and International Law – Finding the Balance?’ (2012) 23 (4) European Journal of International Law 1015

Krisch, Nico ‘The Pluralism of Global Administrative Law’ (2006) 17 (1) European Journal of International Law

Kuo, Ming-Sung ‘The Concept of “Law” in Global Administrative Law: A Reply to Benedict Kingsbury’ (2009) 20 European Journal of International Law

Laker, Thomas ‘The United Nations and the Internal Administration of Justice’ in Clemens A. Feinaugle (ed.), The Rule of Law and its Application to the United Nations (Hart Publishing, 2016)

Landes, David The Wealth and Poverty of Nations (W.W. Norton & Company, 1998)

Lewis, Corinne UNHCR and International Refugee Law: From treaty to innovation (Routledge, 2012)

Lion, Marc ‘Human Rights Obligations and Accountability in the Face of Climate Change’ (2010) 38 Georgia Journal of International and Comparative Law

Loescher, Gil, Alexander Betts and James Milner (eds) The United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR): The Politics and Practice of Refugee Protection into the Twenty-first Century (Routledge, 2008)

Luhmann, Niklas Legitimation durch Verfahren (Suhrkamp, 1969)

Macdonald, Euan and Eran Shamir-Borer ‘Meeting the Challenges of Global Governance; Administrative and Constitutional Approaches’ in Hélène Ruiz Fabri, Rüdiger Wolfrum and Jana Gogolin (eds), Select Proceedings of the European Society of International Law (Volume 2, Bloomsbury Publishing, 2010)

MacDonald, Leighton ‘Positivism and the Formal Rule of Law: Questioning the Connection’ (2001) 26 Australian Journal of Legal Philosophy

Margiev, V.I. ‘On Legal Nature of Internal Law of International Organizations’ (1980) 15 Soviet Year Book of International Law

Marks, Susan ‘Naming Global Administrative Law’ (2005) 37 New York University Journal of International Law and Politics

Marx, Reinhard ‘Non-refoulement, Access to Procedures and Responsibility for Determining Refugee Claims’ (1995) 7 International Journal of Refugee Law

Mashaw, Jerry ‘Administrative Due Process: The Quest for a Dignitary Theory’ (1981) 61 Boston University Law Review

Mashaw, Jerry Bureaucratic Justice: Managing Social Security Disability Claims (Yale University Press, 2003)

Mashaw, Jerry ‘Structuring a “Dense Complexity”; Accountability and the Project of Administrative Law’ (2005) Issues in Legal Scholarship

McCrudden, Christopher ‘Human Dignity and Judicial Interpretation of Human Rights’ (2008) 19 (4) The European Journal of International Law

Megret, Frederic and Florian Hoffman, ‘The UN as a Human Rights Violator?: Some Reflections on the United Nations Changing Human Rights Responsibilities’ (2003) 25 Human Rights Quarterly

Mendelson, Maurice H. ‘The Formation of Customary International Law’ (1998) 272 Recueil des Cours de l’Academie de Droit International

Mortimer, Debra Administrative Justice and its Availability (Federation Press, 2015)

Mulgan, Richard ‘“Accountability”: an Ever-Expanding Concept?’ (2000) 78 Public Administration

Mullan, David J. ‘Fairness: The New Natural Justice’ (1975) 25 University of Toronto Law Journal

Palliari, Balladore ‘Le Droit interne des organisations internationales’ (1969-II) 127 Hague Recueil

Pallis, Mark ‘The Operation of UNHCR’s Accountability Mechanisms’ (2005) 37 International Law and Politics

Peck, J. ‘The U.N. and the Laws of War: How Can the World’s Peacekeepers Be Held Accountable’ (1995) 21 Syracuse Journal of International Law & Commerce

Perlingeiro, Ricardo ‘Contemporary Challenges in Latin American Administrative Justice’ (2016) 3 (2) BRICS Law Journal

Pound, Roscoe ‘Growth of Administrative Justice’ (1922–1924) 2 Wisconsin Law Review

Pronto, Arnold N. ‘“Human-Rightism” and the Development of General International Law’ (2007) 20 Leiden Journal of International Law

Rawls, John A Theory of Justice (Harvard University Press, 1971)

Raz, Joseph The Authority of Law: Essays on Law and Morality (Oxford University Press, 1979)

Reinisch, August, James Crawford and John Bell International Organizations before National Courts (Cambridge University Press, 2004)

Roesch, Ricarda, Giulia Jacovella, Annalisa Bezzi and Juliette Garms ‘The Deficiencies of UNHCR’s RSD Procedure: The Case of Choucha Refugee Camp in Tunisia’ 4 (1) Oxford Monitor of Forced Migration

Rokeach, Milton The Nature of Human Values (Free Press, 1973)

Sales, Philip ‘Judges and Legislature: Values into Law’ (2012) 71 (2) Cambridge Law Journal 289

Salzman, James ‘Decentralized Administrative Law in the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development’ (Summer/Autumn 2005) 68 (175) Law & Contemporary Problems

Schwartz, Bernard French Administrative Law and the Common Law World (The Law Book Exchange Ltd, 2006)

Scoca, Franco Gaetano ‘Administrative Justice in Italy: Origins and Evolutions’ (2009) 2 Italian Journal of Public Law

Selivanov, A. ‘Constitutional Foundations of the Origin and Development of Administrative Justice and Administrative Procedure in the Realization of the Fair Trial Doctrine’ (2012) Law of Ukraine: Legal Journal

Shaw, Malcolm N. International Law (Cambridge University Press, 7th edn, 2014)

Shockley, Tamara ‘The Investigation Procedures of the United Nations Office of Internal Oversight Services and the Rights of the United Nations Staff Member: An Analysis of the United Nations Judicial Tribunals’ Judgements on the Disciplinary Cases in the United Nations’ (2015) XXVII (2) Pace International Law Review

Silvestri, Elisabetta ‘Administrative Justice in Italy’ (2016) III (2) BRICS Law Journal

Slaughter, Anne-Marie ‘The Accountability of Government Networks’ (2000–2001) 8 Indiana Journal of Global Legal Studies

Sossin, Lorne ‘An Intimate Approach to Fairness, Impartiality and Reasonableness in Administrative Law’ (2002) 27 (2) Queen’s Law Journal

Sossin, Lorne ‘Future of Administrative Justice’ (2008) 21 Canadian Journal of Administrative Law & Practice

Sossin, Lorne ‘Designing Administrative Justice: Draft’, British Columbia Continuing Legal Education (BC CLE) Administrative Law Conference, 18 November 2016

Sossin, Lorne and Jamie Baxter ‘Ontario’s Administrative Tribunal Clusters: A Glass Half-Full or Half-Empty for Administrative Justice’ (2012) 12 Oxford Commonwealth Law Journal

Stewart, Richard ‘The Reformation of American Administrative Law’ (1974–1975) 88 Harvard Law Review

Stewart, Richard B. ‘US Administrative Law: A Model for Global Administrative Law?’ (2005) 68 (3&4) Law and Contemporary Problems

Strauss, Peter L. Administrative Justice in the United States (Carolina Academic Press, 2002)

Summers, Robert ‘Evaluating and Improving Legal Processes – A Plea for “Process Values”’ (1974) 60 Cornell Law Review

Tamanaha, Brian Z. On the Rule of Law – History, Politics, Theory (Cambridge University Press, 2004)

Taylor, Savitri ‘The Right to Review in the Australian On-Shore Refugee Status Determination Process: Is it an Adequate Procedural Safeguard Against Refoulement?’ (1993–1994) 2 Federal Law Review

Thibaut, John and Laurens Walker Procedural Justice: A Psychological Analysis (Erlbaum, 1975)

Thibaut, John and Laurens Walker ‘A theory of procedure’ (1978) 66 California Law Review

Tyler, Tom, Degoey, P. and Smith, H.J. ‘Understanding why the justice of group procedures matters: A test of the psychological dynamics of the group value model’ (1996) 70 Journal of Personality and Social Psychology

Verdirame, Guglielmo The UN and Human Rights: Who Guards the Guardians? (Cambridge University Press, 2011)

Wade, William and Christopher Forsyth Administrative Law (Oxford University Press, 7th edn, 1994)

Waldron, Jeremy ‘The Concept and the Rule of Law’ (2008) 43 Georgia Law Review

Waldron, Jeremy ‘Are Sovereigns Entitled to the Benefit of the International Rules of Law?’ (2011) The European Journal of International Law

Walker, Neil Intimations of Global Law (Cambridge University Press, 2015)

Watts, Arthur ‘The International Rule of Law’ (1993) 36 German Yearbook of International Law

White, Nigel D. The Law of International Organisations (Manchester University Press, 2nd edn, 2005)

White, Nigel D. ‘Layers of autonomy in the UN system’ in Richard Collins and Nigel D. White (eds), International Organizations and the Idea of Autonomy (Routledge, 2011)

Williams, Bernard ‘Consequentialism and Integrity’ in S. Scheffler (ed.), Consequentialism and its Critics (Oxford University Press, 1989)

Woods, Jeanne M. ‘A Human Rights Framework for Corporate Accountability’ (2011) 17 ISLA Journal of International and Comparative Law

Wouters, Jan, Eva Brems, Stefaan Smis and Pierre Scmitt (eds), Accountability for Human Rights Violations by International Organisations (Intersentia, 2010)