Perspectives from New Institutional Economics
Edited by Claude Ménard
Chapter 21: Why do the European Union's electricity industries continue to differ? A new institutional analysis
Why do the EU’s electricity industries continue to differ? 313 21. Why do the European Union’s electricity industries continue to differ? A new institutional analysis Jean-Michel Glachant and Dominique Finon INTRODUCTION Why do the last European directive on electricity, No. 96/92 (applicable from February 1999), and the reforms that it brought about in the 15 EU member states, not appear to be promoting a single competition-based model for the electricity industry? Why, since the new British electricity system was opened in April 1990, has not a single EU member state entirely reproduced the English deintegrated competition-based model? Are there objective factors that are likely to make the competition-based reforms among the member states of the European Union develop differently on a long-term basis? What are these differences that are resisting the unifying force of the European Union? In this chapter, we attempt to shed some light on these questions. There is a long list of factors that can explain this or that speciﬁc difference among the reforms being led by the 15 different European states (Gilbert and Kahn 1996; Midttun 1997; Glachant and Finon 2000). The main assumption of our chapter is, however, that the kernel of objective differential factors can be identiﬁed directly from the ‘new institutional analysis’ of the reforms. The technical and economic characteristics of electricity supply and demand in each country are not the only factors that have perpetuated the differences within the industry. Institutions, as well, have played a major role, since reforms...
You are not authenticated to view the full text of this chapter or article.