A Follow-on Innovation Perspective in the Biopharmaceutical Industry
Chapter 7: The Duty to Deal as Applied to Address Technology Access Problems in the Biopharmaceutical Industry
Compulsory licensing is not an absence of patent protection but merely a lessening of that protection. While compulsory licensing may weaken the incentives to invest in pharmaceutical research the trend of rapid and significant increases in investment in pharmaceutical research demonstrates that the present incentives to invest are so strong that they would have to be weakened considerably before there would be any reduction in the amount of pharmaceutical research. 7.1 Conclusions on the patent system in the case of research tools 7.1.1 The Particularity of Research Tools: Pre-commercial Stage Patents The nature of biopharmaceutical research and of the industry in general is such as to potentially give rise to concerns related to refusals to deal or lack access in certain cases. The specific case of research tools was examined in this context. T.C. Bailey, Innovation and Access: The Role of Compulsory Licensing in the Development and Distribution of HIV/AIDS Drugs, 2001 U. Ill. J. L. Tech. & Pol’y 193, p. 207. The latter consists of the full range of resources that scientists use in laboratories, recognising that one institution’s research tool may be another’s end product. NIH Report on Research Tools (1998) op. cit.. They are used to find, refine or design and identify something else that is sold in the marketplace. R. Blackburn in DOJ/FTC Proceedings on the Pharmaceutical Industry: Business Perspectives on the Use and the Role of Patents in the Biotechnology Industry, 26 February 2002. Many research tools are expensive to develop and have significant competitive value...
You are not authenticated to view the full text of this chapter or article.