Considering a New Constitutional Settlement for Scotland
Chapter 7: A Restatement of the Case for Scottish Fiscal Autonomy
In this chapter we rebut the case that Ashcroft et al. (2006) make in favour of the status quo fiscal settlement in Scotland that stems from the Scotland Act 1998 and address their criticisms of our proposal for fiscal autonomy outlined in the previous chapter. Their case for Barnett is that it offers a hard budget constraint that effectively disciplines the Scottish public sector. We will show in this chapter that this belief in Barnett is based on a serious misconception of its economic consequences. Despite the fact that Barnett sets an upper limit on public spending by the Scottish Government it is by no means a hard budget constraint. Indeed, so poor is its fiscal discipline on the Executive that it is better described as a formula for a ‘Rakes Progress’. THE FLAWED CASE FOR BARNETT Ashcroft et al. (2006) provide a table in which they compare the characteristics of the Barnett formula system for financing devolved Scottish Government spending with that of fiscal autonomy of the type that we discussed in the last chapter. According to them, like fiscal autonomy, the Barnett formula offers a hard budget constraint and is efficient at handling the split of resources between the Scottish public and private sectors. They say ‘no attempt is made in this table to indicate the degree or extent to which each characteristic is present in each system’. However, they do say that: The present Barnett based system already exhibits many of the characteristics required to encourage the...
You are not authenticated to view the full text of this chapter or article.
Elgaronline requires a subscription or purchase to access the full text of books or journals. Please login through your library system or with your personal username and password on the homepage.
Non-subscribers can freely search the site, view abstracts/ extracts and download selected front matter and introductory chapters for personal use.
Your library may not have purchased all subject areas. If you are authenticated and think you should have access to this title, please contact your librarian.